For debate, in addition to the team championship, Asbury and Berger earned first and second place speaker awards, respectively. Overall, the teams secured victories over schools such as the University of Northern Iowa, Augustana, and Western Illinois University. In 2004, Illinois State’s debate team was revitalized after a several year hiatus. In 2005, they won the best newcomer award, a prestigious award given to the best up-and-coming program in the Midwest. The teams travel next to the Notre Dame tournament in February.
For the forensics team, eight students placed in elimination rounds during the first half of the swing tournament hosted by the University of Nebraska, Lincoln, including a first-place finish by Andrew Kudla (senior, English) in Program Oral Interpretation. During the second day of the swing, hosted by Kansas State University, ten forensics team members made it to the elimination rounds, with five individuals placing first. Kudla won Persuasive Speaking, Kelly McCarthy (senior, Communication) won Poetry Interpretation, Jordan Bryant (junior, Communication) won Program Oral Interpretation, Jamie Downing (sophomore, Communication) won Extemporaneous Speaking, and Ryan Henneberry (first-year, Social Sciences) won Informative Speaking.
Since 1995, Illinois State's forensics team has placed in the top three in the nation every year, including four national championships. The forensics team is the defending national champion of the American Forensics Association.